Skip to main content

Self-Canceling Installment Notes (SCIN)

A self-canceling installment note (SCIN) is a promissory note, used when you sell an asset to a family member or a family trust, that is automatically canceled if you die before it is paid off. It is a specialized technique, typically considered by older sellers whose health is below average but who are not terminally ill.

What it is

In an ordinary installment sale, you sell an asset and the buyer pays you over time. If you die before the note is paid, the remaining balance is an asset of your estate. A SCIN adds one feature: the unpaid balance is canceled at your death, so nothing remaining on the note is included in your estate.

That cancellation feature has value to the buyer, so the law requires the seller to be paid for it. A SCIN therefore carries a “risk premium,” either a higher interest rate or a higher sale price than an ordinary note. The premium is typically calculated with IRS mortality tables. Without an adequate premium, part of the sale may be treated as a gift.

The problem it addresses

Some families hold a business or investment that the older generation wants to transfer, but the parent also needs income from it and has a shorter-than-average life expectancy. An outright gift could use much of the lifetime exemption, and an ordinary sale leaves the unpaid note in the estate.

A SCIN can address both. The seller receives payments during life, and if the seller dies early, the balance disappears from the estate. The IRS tables assume average health, so a seller who dies sooner than the tables predict may, in effect, receive less than the premium anticipated, and the family keeps the difference. That result is not assured, because the IRS has taken the position that the seller’s actual health must be considered when the note is valued.

How it works

  1. Your attorney and CPA confirm that the seller is not terminally ill under the tax regulations, and that the term of the note is shorter than the seller’s life expectancy.
  2. A qualified appraisal sets the value of the asset, such as interests in a family business or entity.
  3. The buyer, often a child or a grantor trust, signs a note with a risk premium and agrees to make regular payments. The buyer needs a genuine ability to pay.
  4. The seller receives interest and principal payments during the term. In a sale to a family member, the seller generally reports the interest and the gain under the installment rules. A sale to a grantor trust is generally disregarded for income tax while grantor trust status lasts.
  5. If the seller dies before the note is paid, the balance is canceled and is generally not included in the estate. If the seller survives the term, the note is simply paid in full, including the premium.

Who it typically suits

  • Older sellers with health concerns that shorten life expectancy, who are not terminally ill.
  • Owners of a business or income-producing asset who want to transfer it while receiving payments.
  • Families with a buyer, or a trust, that can realistically make the note payments.

Key risks and trade-offs

  • IRS scrutiny. In advice released in 2013, which cannot be cited as precedent, IRS lawyers said a SCIN should be valued on a willing-buyer, willing-seller basis that reflects the seller’s actual health, not the standard tables, and they questioned whether the notes were genuine debt. The related Davidson estate case settled in 2015 without a court ruling, so the question remains open. One federal appeals court has also said a family SCIN is presumed to be a gift unless a real expectation of repayment and intent to collect are shown. Documentation and a realistic expectation of payment matter.
  • The seller outlives expectations. If the seller lives through the term, the buyer pays the full price plus the premium, which can move more value back into the seller’s estate.
  • Income tax at death. A leading court decision treated deferred gain on a canceled SCIN as taxable income to the seller’s estate, and the IRS has taken a similar view, so the cancellation may not erase the income tax.
  • Uncertain buyer basis. How the buyer’s cost basis is determined when the note cancels is not fully settled, which can affect a later sale.
  • Interest treatment. Whether the buyer can deduct the interest depends on how the asset is used. A sale to a grantor trust is treated differently.

Working with your attorney and CPA

GSG can prepare financial projections of a SCIN and an ordinary installment sale under different life spans for you and your advisors to review. Your attorney drafts the note and sale documents and advises on the health and bona fide sale requirements. Your CPA coordinates the appraisal and premium calculation and handles the income tax reporting for both sides.

Some families also consider life insurance for liquidity.

Frequently asked questions

How does a SCIN compare with a private annuity?

A private annuity pays the seller for life, however long that is, and is typically unsecured. A SCIN has a fixed term and can be secured. Under proposed regulations, a private annuity may also cause the seller’s gain to be taxed at the outset, while a SCIN generally keeps installment reporting.

Who can be the buyer?

Often a child or a trust for the children. The asset’s income or the buyer’s own resources must realistically support the payments.

What if the seller’s health is very poor?

If the seller is terminally ill under the regulations, the standard tables cannot be used, and the SCIN may not achieve its purpose. Your attorney will review medical facts before any sale.

Related strategies

Talk to us. If you would like to learn more about this topic, contact Generational Strategies Group to start a conversation.

This page is provided by Generational Strategies Group, LLC, 5150 Tamiami Trail N, Suite 600, Naples, FL 34103, for general educational purposes only. It is not legal, tax or investment advice, it does not recommend any strategy or product, and it does not describe any particular person’s situation. Tax laws change and outcomes depend on individual facts. Please consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any strategy described here. Generational Strategies Group is not a law firm or CPA firm and does not provide legal or tax advice, and this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. Any projections are illustrations based on assumptions, not predictions of results. Life insurance and annuities are offered by licensed insurance agents, who act as agents for the issuing insurers. Coverage is subject to underwriting, and policy guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.