Charitable Lead Unitrust (CLUT)
A Charitable Lead Unitrust (CLUT) is an irrevocable trust that pays charity a fixed percentage of the trust’s value each year for a set term, then passes what remains to family. It suits charitably minded families, particularly those planning for grandchildren, who want a lead trust whose charitable payments rise and fall with the investments.
What it is
A CLUT belongs to the same family as the Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT). Both pay charity first, for a term of years, and both leave the remainder to family members or to trusts for them. The difference is how the charity’s payment is measured.
A CLAT pays a fixed dollar amount. A CLUT pays a fixed percentage of the trust’s assets, revalued every year. If the investments grow, the charity’s payment grows with them; if they fall, the payment falls too. The value of the family’s remainder is calculated at funding, and that value is the taxable gift.
The problem it addresses
Families who want to support charity and pass wealth to the next generation often look first at a CLAT. A CLAT works well when the goal is to shift as much growth as possible to children, but it has a weakness when grandchildren are involved: the amount of generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax exemption protecting the remainder is not settled until the term ends.
A CLUT addresses that problem. Because the GST exemption is allocated against a value fixed at funding, the family can know from the start whether the remainder is fully protected from GST tax. That makes a CLUT a natural fit for a trust meant to benefit grandchildren or to continue for several generations.
How it works
- Your attorney drafts the trust, naming the charities, the term, the annual payout percentage and the family members or trusts that will receive the remainder.
- You fund the trust with assets such as securities or interests in a family entity, either during life or at death through your estate plan.
- The remainder’s value is fixed at funding. For a trust benefiting grandchildren, GST exemption can be allocated to that value on the gift-tax return.
- Each year, the trustee revalues the assets and pays charity the set percentage of that year’s value.
- At the end of the term, the remaining assets pass to your family or to continuing trusts, outside your taxable estate.
Who it typically suits
- Families with an ongoing charitable commitment who want the remainder to benefit grandchildren or later generations.
- Donors who want certainty about GST exemption at the outset rather than at the end of the term.
- Charities and donors comfortable with payments that vary with investment performance.
- Families pairing a lead trust with a dynasty or generation-skipping trust for the remainder.
Key risks and trade-offs
- Less leverage than a CLAT. Because the charity shares in the growth every year, a CLUT generally passes less of the upside to the family than a CLAT with similar terms. A CLUT also cannot be “zeroed-out” in the same way.
- Payments are not predictable. A strong year raises the next payment to charity; a weak year lowers it.
- Annual valuation. The trust must be revalued every year, which adds cost and complexity when it holds hard-to-value assets such as private business interests or real estate.
- Grantor versus non-grantor design. As with a CLAT, a grantor CLUT may provide an up-front income-tax deduction but leaves you taxed on trust income, with possible recapture if you die during the term; a non-grantor CLUT is its own taxpayer.
- Irrevocable. The terms are fixed at funding, and the assets keep their original cost basis rather than receiving a step-up at death.
Working with your attorney and CPA
GSG does not draft trusts or give legal or tax advice. GSG can prepare financial projections of a CLUT and a CLAT under different return assumptions for you and your advisors to review. We then coordinate with your estate-planning attorney, who drafts the trust and the continuing trusts for descendants, and with your CPA, who prepares the gift-tax return, allocates GST exemption and handles the annual valuation and reporting.
Some families consider life insurance held in a separate irrevocable trust for liquidity or for the risk of the donor’s death during the term.
Frequently asked questions
Should we choose a CLAT or a CLUT?
It depends on the goal. A CLAT often shifts more growth to children; a CLUT often fits better when grandchildren are the remainder beneficiaries and GST certainty matters most.
Does the Section 7520 rate matter for a CLUT?
It matters less than it does for a CLAT, because the charity’s payment already moves with the trust’s value. The payout percentage and the term have the larger effect on the remainder.
Can the charity be our family foundation?
Often, yes, although special rules apply when family members who benefit from the remainder also direct the foundation. Your attorney will address this in drafting.
Related strategies
- Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT) — the fixed-payment version of the same lead trust
- Generation Skipping Trust — a common recipient of a CLUT’s remainder for grandchildren
- Dynasty Trust — can carry the remainder forward for several generations
- Family Foundation — a common recipient of the CLUT’s annual payments
Talk to us. If you would like to learn more about this topic, contact Generational Strategies Group to start a conversation.
This page is provided by Generational Strategies Group, LLC, 5150 Tamiami Trail N, Suite 600, Naples, FL 34103, for general educational purposes only. It is not legal, tax or investment advice, it does not recommend any strategy or product, and it does not describe any particular person’s situation. Tax laws change and outcomes depend on individual facts. Please consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any strategy described here. Generational Strategies Group is not a law firm or CPA firm and does not provide legal or tax advice, and this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. Any projections are illustrations based on assumptions, not predictions of results. Life insurance and annuities are offered by licensed insurance agents, who act as agents for the issuing insurers. Coverage is subject to underwriting, and policy guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.